101st Annual Meeting

Due to restrictions on in-person gatherings, the 2020 business meeting of the Plymouth Antiquarian Society was held virtually via Zoom on November 21, 2020. Authorization for remote-only meetings during the coronavirus pandemic was given to nonprofit organizations by Governor Baker and the Massachusetts legislature.

Annual Meeting 

Call to Order – Virginia E. Davis, President
Moment of Silence in Memory of Monica M. Donelan – Virginia E. Davis, President
Presentation of Nominees to the Board of Trustees – Susan Fessenden, Nominating Committee Chair
Presentation of Nominees to Nominating Committee for 2021 – Virginia E. Davis, President
Treasurer’s Remarks – Charles E. Vautrain III, Treasurer
President’s Remarks – Virginia E. Davis, President
Director’s Remarks – Anne Mason, Executive Director
Adjournment – Virginia E. Davis, President


“Sometimes fortune Smiled other times a hard rub”: The Bilbao Adventures of Plymouth’s Captain Nathaniel Spooner
Presented by Donald C. Carleton, Jr. with comments by Dr. Xabier Lamikiz

As the ward of his uncle Ephraim Spooner, the Plymouth shipmaster Nathaniel Spooner (1758-1826) was raised in the house at 27 North Street now preserved by the Plymouth Antiquarian Society, whose rich historical collections include Nathaniel’s portrait and spyglass.

In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, Spooner skippered multiple voyages from Massachusetts to Spain delivering cargoes of cod and other foodstuffs to hungry Iberian consumers on behalf of his employers, the Plymouth merchants Thomas and William Davis. Despite the disordered international situation at the time, Spooner managed to complete most of his voyages without undue incident.

In August of 1803, however, Spooner’s luck ran out. While departing the Spanish Basque port of Bilbao, his schooner the Governor Carver was intercepted on suspicion of carrying specie, a serious crime at a time when the export of gold and silver by foreign traders was generally prohibited by law. The story of the Captain’s hair’s-breadth escape from justice and the legal machinations that followed is now being pieced together from surviving manuscript records by our speaker, independent scholar Donald C. Carleton, Jr., in collaboration with Bilbao’s Itsasmuseum (maritime museum) and Dr. Xabier Lamikiz of the University of the Basque Country.

About the Presenters
Donald C. Carleton, Jr., is an independent curator/researcher and a nonresident research associate of the Itsasmuseum Bilbao. He trained at Harvard and Brown, where he earned his MA in history in 2008. He is currently developing a public history project exploring New England’s multifaceted connections with the Iberian world with a focus on the North Shore’s nearly two century-long trading relationship with the Spanish Basque port of Bilbao. In 2013 he curated the commemorative exhibition 1763: A Revolutionary Peace at Boston’s Old State House Museum.

Xabier Lamikiz is Associate Professor of Economic History at the University of the Basque Country. He received his Ph.D. from the University of London in 2006. Dr. Lamikiz’s publications include Trade and Trust in the Eighteenth-Century Atlantic World: Spanish Merchants and Their Overseas Networks (2010) and articles on early-modern Spanish trade and shipping in the International Journal of Maritime History, Hispanic American Historical Review, Colonial Latin American Review, and Journal of Iberian and Latin American Economic History.